TL;DR
Get home appliances delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
A Hey Der Folks YouTube creator tested the $200 All American Sharpener Model 5005 Gen 2 on three zero-turn mower blades and reported a quick, consistent result. The jig guides an angle grinder rather than sharpening blades on its own; whether the price makes sense depends on how often a buyer sharpens blades.
A Hey Der Folks YouTube creator tested the $200 All American Sharpener Model 5005 Gen 2 on three blades from a zero-turn lawn mower and said the bench-mounted jig made sharpening quick and consistent, even for a first-time user. The test suggests the tool can simplify guiding an angle grinder, but it does not establish that the price is worthwhile for homeowners who sharpen blades only occasionally.
The Model 5005 Gen 2 is a blade-holding and grinder-guiding jig, not a self-contained sharpener. An adjustable grip secures a mower blade, while an arm guides an angle grinder along its bevel. Buyers must supply the grinder. The guide angle can be adjusted from 15 to 45 degrees to accommodate different blades.
For the test, the creator bolted the sharpener to a scrap piece of 2-by-4 lumber and clamped the wood to a workbench. At a 35-degree setting, he said three strokes were enough to produce a clearer edge. He sharpened three blades for his zero-turn mower, describing the arm’s motion as smooth and saying the angle did not change unexpectedly. Those are the tester’s observations, not a controlled comparison of blade performance or durability.
Hunker also cited testing by Bob Vila reviewers, who assessed eight sharpeners. They reportedly gave the All American model a perfect score for ease of use, efficiency and quality, and found it produced the most consistent result among the products tested. Assembly took about 10 minutes, according to that review. Its value score was lower: 4.3 out of 5.
Who Can Recover the $200 Cost?
The test highlights a practical trade-off for mower owners: the jig may make a repetitive sharpening task easier to control, but the up-front cost is substantial compared with simpler tools. A buyer also needs an angle grinder and a secure work surface, so the $200 price is not the full cost of setting up to use it.
Frequency of use is central to the value question. The tester owned six blades—three on his zero-turn mower and three spares—and said professional sharpening savings could eventually cover the purchase price. He also cautioned that it would take time. For a homeowner with a single-blade push mower who sharpens once a year or less, a file or lower-cost sharpener may be a more economical choice. The report does not provide a price-per-sharpening comparison, so the payback period will vary with local service prices and use.
Products Worth Considering
Hisense 40-Inch Class QD4SR Series Hi-QLED FHD Smart Roku TV (2026 Model)
Hisense 43-Inch E6SR Series Hi-QLED 4K UHD Smart Roku TV (2026 Model)
Arlo Ultra 4K HDR Wireless Security Camera (3rd Gen), 3-Camera Kit with SmartHub
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
How the Guided Grinder Works
Sharpening a mower blade with an angle grinder involves following the existing bevel while holding the blade securely. The All American unit is designed to address the challenge of keeping the grinder aligned: its adjustable arm guides the grinder while the blade remains clamped. It helps control the angle, but the user still operates the grinder and must set up the equipment properly.
The Hey Der Folks tester said he attached the jig to lumber and clamped it to his bench. That setup is part of the test account, not a claim that every work surface or blade will be suitable. Hunker notes that less expensive options include drill-powered sharpeners, manual sharpeners and files. Similar guide-arm tools are also available for about $50 and up, though the report says users have found some of them flimsy. It does not provide a model-by-model comparison or independent durability testing for those alternatives.
“I never had it bog down, it never unexpectedly changed my angle … just very smooth consistently.”
— Hey Der Folks YouTube creator, as quoted by Hunker
Questions the Test Does Not Settle
The account describes one creator’s experience sharpening three blades, but it does not report controlled measurements of cutting performance, long-term durability or results across different mower blade designs. It also does not establish whether the 35-degree setting is appropriate for every blade; the product’s angle range is adjustable, and the correct setup may depend on the blade.
The available report does not state how much the creator paid for professional sharpening, how often he sharpens his blades, or how many uses would be needed to recoup the tool’s price. Bob Vila’s scores offer a second review perspective, but the cited information does not give enough detail to compare every tested model, test conditions or long-term ownership costs. The creator’s positive comments therefore should not be read as proof that the tool is the best choice for all homeowners.
The Value Depends on Use
No additional testing or product announcement is described in the source report. For prospective buyers, the practical next step is to compare the purchase price with local sharpening fees and estimate how many blades they will sharpen each season. Owners should also account for the angle grinder, setup space and any time needed to install the jig.
People considering the tool can compare its guided-arm design with lower-cost files, manual sharpeners and grinder attachments, while checking that a chosen method suits their mower blade. The source does not report follow-up results from the creator or a confirmed payback period; the cost question remains dependent on each buyer’s equipment and sharpening schedule.
Key Questions
What happened when the creator tested the $200 sharpener?
The Hey Der Folks creator used the jig with an angle grinder to sharpen three zero-turn mower blades. He said the process was quick and consistent, and reported that three strokes at a 35-degree setting produced a clearer edge.
Does the All American Sharpener include an angle grinder?
No. The Model 5005 Gen 2 is a guide and blade holder; the angle grinder is not included. The tool’s arm guides a grinder along the blade bevel.
Is the $200 tool worth it for an occasional homeowner?
The source report does not establish a universal answer. The tester said the cost could eventually be recovered through avoided professional sharpening fees, but added that it would take a while. Someone who sharpens rarely may prefer a less expensive file or sharpener.
What other reviews were cited?
Hunker cited Bob Vila reviewers who tested eight sharpeners. They reportedly rated this model perfectly for ease of use, efficiency and quality, while giving it 4.3 out of 5 for value.
Source: hunker.com
